Wednesday, January 19, 2011

A measure of evil

Take a little stroll down to your local grocery store to buy bread and milk and you will find almost without exception that you are required to go to both the back left and back right corners of the store to acquire them.  It is standard retail practice to set up the store in such a way that customers have to walk as far as possible to get their basic necessities to maximize their chances of making impulse buys and grocery stores are no exception.  I was wondering a little while ago just how much evil these places are capable of.  Specifically I was trying to sort out if they deliberately took cashiers off duty when the lines got fairly low to make sure customers always had to wait.  A significant chunk of the store's profit comes from people buying items at the checkout counters like chocolate bars and magazines because those items have such huge margins, but does the store deliberately inconvenience customers in an attempt to sell more of those?  I know that they will never call extra cashiers until the lines are completely blocking the aisles and people simply can't move about the store reasonably at all, so I know they are not trying to avoid congestion.  I know they immediately remove cashiers as soon as the lines stop being a congested mess and never leave cashiers working long enough to get the lines down to 1-2 people.  Do they deliberately set it up such that customers must wait in line just to sell more magazines?  I don't know, but it since their system seems like the optimal one if their only desire is to sell addons I suspect this is exactly what they do.  Unfortunately I don't think they consider how many sales they lose when customers get disgusted with the congestion and wait times and go elsewhere for their purchases, which hurts them as well as the people standing in line.

Grocery stores obviously aren't the only places that are guilty of shenanigans.  Back in the summer when I was in the local health food / herbal medicine store I listened to a conversation between a staff member and a customer about buying herbal supplements for the health problems the customer had.  The customer related how his doctor had been unable to solve his problem to his satisfaction and asked what supplements the store would recommend.  The staffer answered "Some people find this works" while pointing to a particular bottle, but when the customer asked about other solutions the staffer gave precisely the same answer about everything that came up.  The customer got more and more agitated, seeking answers and information instead of platitudes, but came up empty handed.  I wanted to jump in and say "Those random herbs are all equally good for your problem - they will all help exactly as much as you would expect from a placebo." but decided that the customer was probably headed to that conclusion on his own.  It makes me crazy to see these stores set up sections with racks and racks of 'cures' organized by the problems they are supposed to assist with.  If the damn things worked you would have confidence intervals and descriptions and information for the customer; instead they only offer the plausible deniability of not being dangerous.  My favourite quote on the subject is one from Tim Minchin "You know what they call alternative medicine that works?  MEDICINE!"

I am certainly not innocent in the realm of fleecing customers.  A 5 year stint in retail selling mattresses is not the place to hone your sense of justice but it is a great learning experience if you want to understand exactly how and when people lie, obfuscate and misdirect.  The only thing I really want to know is whether the people involved in selling all these fictions and directing customers to their will really know exactly what they are doing or simply manage to be evil and dastardly by accident.

6 comments:

  1. The Metro beside where I live practically never has lines longer than 1 or 2 people. When it does happen it tends to be because the credit card system is down at one of the checkouts and even then I've never been more than 3 or 4 people back in a line.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, every store has the setup of necessities at the back corners but not all of them have a system that seems to try to keep the lines long, that is only my store in my experience.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I find the service at the stores really depends on the stores that you frequent. The local "cheap" grocery stores will usually have lineups while more expensive stores don't... even in the same time frame. I don't think its because they want to get more money from impulse sales, but simply its cheaper for them if they have people waiting... and I think only a very small percentage of people will actually leave because of the line-ups. Its a much bigger pain for me to go get my groceries elsewhere then it is for me to simply wait in line.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I doubt very much you would leave on a given day to go to another store. However, you might well shop at a different store next time if the experience is bad.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It would have to be _really_ bad. I'm adding like 20 minutes onto my trip if I go to a different store, so unless I could guarantee saving at least that much time it just doesn't seem worthwhile.

    ReplyDelete
  6. True, in your case that is an issue. However, even though I live right near my store I go near by another store on my way to pick up Elli and I regularly go there just because the alternate store has short lines and the food and prices are basically the same. It is further from my house but I avoid my local Metro whenever it is convenient to do so, and I wouldn't do that if they actually kept enough cashiers working to keep the lines reasonable. Some people can't or won't shop elsewhere, but some can and will.

    ReplyDelete