You read that right. Guessing at random would give you 4 correct, but the average person is significantly worse than random guessing. The author of the book talks about how in all his years administering these questions to huge numbers of people one person ever got 11 correct, and nobody got 12.
I got 11 correct, and I definitely should have got 12, but I rushed through. That isn't because I am smarter than everyone else, but because the author of the book was trying to make a point, showing how badly humans do on specific sorts of knowledge, and that is a specific sort of knowledge I focus on.
The idea behind the book is that we are terrible at interpreting certain sorts of data and the information we are exposed to predisposes us to come to incorrect conclusions. The book clarifies a lot of important facts that we usually get wrong, and provides techniques for preventing yourself from reaching those incorrect conclusions in future. It is a combination of science, sociology, and psychology. Through reading it we learn about what scientific research and facts tell us about the human world, why we get it wrong, and how we can make our brains be better at this sort of thing.
The key takeaway is that a lot of things are getting better. For example, I have gotten into a few heated discussions about pollution where people tried to convince me that pollution is getting worse everywhere. I brought up air quality in Toronto, and these people stated that it is getting worse every year. I pointed out that we can falsify this both anecdotally and scientifically - just think about the smog pouring out of car tailpipes in decades past, and look at car tailpipes today. Or, you know, you can just look up the numbers and see that air quality in Toronto has been constantly improving ever since we were able to measure it.
Lots of things are like this. People see disasters on the news or charities begging for help with images of catastrophe and fail to realize that while individual problems exist, the global trend for nearly all measures of human well being is constantly improving. We miss the forest for the trees.
Of course that doesn't mean we should rest on our laurels! Both the author and I are convinced that we should do more for environmental causes and assisting those less fortunate in the world, but we should do that while being aware of the successes we have had. "We have a lot more to do" can go along with "Many things are improving rapidly" without contradiction.
Everyone should read this book. If all you get from it is a new understanding of global trends it will be worth it, but you can get so much more. It can give you tools to be a better activist, a better environmentalist, and a better thinker.
I've put a hold on it, but my suspicion is that it will just tell me things I already know but that most people won't. If so, I will be sending accusing glares your way.
ReplyDeleteIf, on the other hand, it teaches me a bunch of new and interesting things that I can shock and awe others at parties with, then I'll be very grateful that you suggested it.